Elev8 Creamy Rice Flavors Ranked: Our Best Sellers

Elev8 Creamy Rice Flavors Ranked: Our Best Sellers!

We’ve sold a lot of Elev8 Foods Creamy Rice at NF Supps — and after tracking every flavor across thousands of orders, we finally have a definitive answer to the question every customer asks: which flavor is the best?

We pulled our all-time sales data and ranked every Elev8 Creamy Rice flavor currently in stock — so this isn’t just our opinion. These rankings are based on what our customers have actually bought, repeatedly, since day one. Here’s the definitive Elev8 Creamy Rice flavor ranking.

#1 — Chocolate Cake 🎂

All-time units sold: 1,249

The undisputed #1. Chocolate Cake has outsold every other Elev8 Creamy Rice flavor at NF Supps and it’s not particularly close. It delivers a rich, deep chocolate flavor that tastes like dessert in a bowl — which is exactly what makes it so addictive as a post-workout meal or morning carb source.

Chocolate Cake pairs perfectly with chocolate or vanilla whey protein, and it’s the flavor that converts people who are skeptical about cream of rice into daily users. If you’ve never tried Elev8 Creamy Rice, this is where you start.

#2 — Cinnamon Roll 🍞

All-time units sold: 1,119

A close second — and the morning training crowd’s favorite. Cinnamon Roll tastes exactly like a warm cinnamon roll fresh out of the oven: sweet, spiced, and incredibly comforting. It’s the flavor that makes eating your pre-workout carbs feel like a reward rather than a chore.

Cinnamon Roll is the #1 choice for athletes who train in the morning and want something that feels like breakfast. Pair it with vanilla whey and a drizzle of honey for the ultimate pre-workout bowl.

#3 — Cookies & Cream 🍪

All-time units sold: 662

Cookies & Cream is the dessert flavor that bridges the gap between Chocolate Cake and something lighter. It’s got that classic Oreo-inspired combination of chocolate cookie and cream that’s sweet, balanced, and incredibly satisfying. It’s the flavor for athletes who love chocolate but want something a little less intense than straight Chocolate Cake.

#4 — Blueberry Muffin 🫐

All-time units sold: 602

Blueberry Muffin is the top fruit-forward flavor in the lineup — and it’s genuinely one of the best. It tastes like a warm blueberry muffin: sweet, slightly tart, and bakery-fresh. It’s the flavor that works best as an overnight prep (mix with Greek yogurt and refrigerate overnight) or as a morning bowl topped with fresh blueberries and granola.

#5 — Peanut Butter Cup 🥜

All-time units sold: 579

Peanut Butter Cup is the flavor for athletes who want maximum indulgence in their carb source. Rich peanut butter flavor with a chocolate undertone — it tastes like a Reese’s in bowl form. Pair it with chocolate whey and a drizzle of peanut butter for one of the best post-workout meals in the game. It’s also the best Elev8 flavor for bulking — add nut butter on top and the calories stack up fast.

#6 — Apple Pie 🫐

All-time units sold: 424

Apple Pie is the fall flavor that works year-round. Sweet apple with warm cinnamon spice — it’s comforting, familiar, and genuinely delicious. It’s one of the most unique flavors in the lineup and a great option for athletes who want something fruit-forward without going full berry. Top it with diced apple and granola for the full experience.

#7 — Maple & Brown Sugar 🍁

All-time units sold: 417

Maple & Brown Sugar is the classic oatmeal flavor reimagined in cream of rice form. Sweet, warm, and deeply satisfying — it’s the flavor that feels most like a traditional breakfast. It’s the go-to for athletes who want something that tastes like real food rather than a supplement. Add walnuts and banana for the ultimate morning bowl.

#8 — Cookie Butter 🍪

All-time units sold: 412

Cookie Butter is one of the most unique flavors in the entire Elev8 lineup — inspired by the Belgian speculoos cookie spread that’s become a cult favorite. It’s warm, spiced, and sweet with a caramel-cookie depth that’s unlike anything else in the cream of rice space. If you’ve never had cookie butter, this is the flavor that will make you a convert.

#9 — Carrot Cake 🥕

All-time units sold: 332

Carrot Cake is the sleeper hit of the lineup — a flavor that sounds unusual for a performance carb source but tastes incredible. Warm spices, sweet carrot, and a cream cheese-inspired finish make this one of the most complex and satisfying flavors Elev8 makes. It’s the flavor that surprises people the most on first taste.

#10 — Coconut Cream 🥥

All-time units sold: 263

Coconut Cream is the tropical option — light, sweet, and refreshing with a genuine coconut flavor that works beautifully in the cream of rice format. It’s the most versatile flavor in the lineup — works equally well as a sweet bowl topped with mango and toasted coconut, or as a savory base cooked with chicken broth. A great choice for athletes who want something different from the dessert-forward flavors.

#11 — Salted Caramel 🍬

All-time units sold: 185

Salted Caramel is the sophisticated choice — sweet caramel with a subtle salt finish that balances the sweetness perfectly. It’s one of the most elegant flavors in the lineup and pairs beautifully with vanilla whey, pecans, and a banana. A great option for athletes who want something sweet but not over-the-top.

#12 — Georgia Peach 🍑

All-time units sold: 123

Georgia Peach is the lightest, most refreshing flavor in the lineup — a sweet, juicy peach profile that’s perfect for summer training. It’s the newest flavor to build its sales history, but the flavor profile is excellent and it’s a great option for athletes who want something fruit-forward and refreshing rather than a dessert-style bowl.

The Full In-Stock Ranking at a Glance

Rank	Flavor	All-Time Units Sold	Profile
#1	Chocolate Cake	1,249	Rich, deep chocolate dessert
#2	Cinnamon Roll	1,119	Warm, sweet cinnamon spice
#3	Cookies & Cream	662	Chocolate cookie and cream
#4	Blueberry Muffin	602	Sweet, tart bakery blueberry
#5	Peanut Butter Cup	579	Rich PB with chocolate undertone
#6	Apple Pie	424	Sweet apple with cinnamon spice
#7	Maple & Brown Sugar	417	Classic warm breakfast sweetness
#8	Cookie Butter	412	Spiced Belgian speculoos cookie
#9	Carrot Cake	332	Warm spice with cream cheese finish
#10	Coconut Cream	263	Light, tropical, versatile
#11	Salted Caramel	185	Sweet caramel with salt finish
#12	Georgia Peach	123	Light, juicy, refreshing peach

Note: Strawberry Cheesecake (Limited Edition) and Churro Fiesta are currently out of stock. Strawberry Cheesecake was our #3 all-time seller with 1,011 units — keep an eye out for a restock.

The Formula Behind Every Flavor

No matter which flavor you choose, every serving of Elev8 Foods Creamy Rice delivers:

• 27g Complex Carbohydrates — rapidly replenishes glycogen stores for faster recovery and sustained energy
• 0g Sugar — clean carbs without the blood sugar spike
• 122 Calories per Serving — easy to track and stack with your protein and supplement routine
• 25 Servings per Container — long-lasting supply at great value
• All-Natural Ingredients — no artificial fillers or proprietary blends

Shop Elev8 Foods Creamy Rice at NF Supps

All 12 in-stock flavors of Elev8 Foods Creamy Rice are available now at NF Supps — Cleveland’s home for premium sports nutrition. Start with the #1 Chocolate Cake if you’re new to the lineup, or grab a few flavors to rotate through the week.

Shop Elev8 Foods Creamy Rice at NF Supps →

Have a favorite Elev8 flavor that surprised you? Stop by our Cleveland store and let us know — we love hearing what our customers are reaching for.