Free Shipping Over $99


Your Cart is Empty

Fit Butters High-Protein Nut Butter Spreads

Rated 4.8 out of 5
Based on 4 reviews

FIt Butters are the ONLY nut butters on the market that tells you exactly what BRAND and FLAVOR of high quality protein is used in the nut butters.

FIt Butters has partnered with some of the world's premier sports nutrition brands to provide the highest quality protein possible in a nut butter.

FIt Butter Benefits:

  • ALL nuts roasted in-house
  • HIGHEST quality protein sources
  • HEALTHY fats from nuts and coconut oil
  • FRIENDLY macros for the fitness loving lifestyle
  • EVERY jar created with love and care from FIt Butters


The FIt Butters team roasted Spanish peanuts in a perfect smooth blend of peanuts, delicious toffee crunch and sweet add of butterscotch to send your mouth on a rollercoaster of flavor. This texture goes great on English muffins, toast, or even by the spoonful! Try out this perfect match between crunch and sweet. Something about a crunch satisfies a craving better than any other. Butterscotch chips not only melted into the nut butter but mixed on top with toffee bits. Are you drooling yet?

Our Butterscotch Toffee Crunch Peanut Butter is made with high quality BEAM Whey Protein Isolate. Their Salted Peanut Butter flavored whey protein isolate is the perfect compliment to butterscotch and toffee used in this peanut butter spread.


One of the greatest Girl Scout Cookies of all-time is the Caramel Delight (aka Samoa). This cannot be argued. FIt Butters was able to create a replica of this amazing cookie but in nut butter form.

We combined the creamy texture of cashew with the flavor of almonds as the base for our Caramel Fudge Coconut Cookie nut butter. This makes the nut butter spreadable, but also enjoyable by the spoonful.

We incorporate REAL Caramel Coconut Fudge Cookies with sugar-free syrup and unsweetened coconut flakes to give you the experience you've been dying for. This may very well be our best creation yet!

With every single bite you get the flavor, the texture and the visual cue you want when you think about your Girl Scout favorite.

FIt Butters perfected the flavor of Caramel Fudge Coconut Cookie by infusing the base with Purus Labs Savory Chocolate Cream Keto Feed. Keto Feed from Purus Labs incorporate healthy fats from MCTs making this a keto friendly protein, this making this FIt Butter Keto Friendly! On top of the healthy fats, Keto Feed is one of the best tasting proteins on the market which allows us to give you one of the best tasting nut butters on the planet.


Hungry? Why wait! It is finally here, the much anticipated Chocolate Caramel Candy Bar peanut butter. We all know that grabbing a Snickers bar isn't feasible for a lot of our diets, but this nut butter is!

We start with dry roasted peanuts. We toast the peanuts over an open flame, just like all of the nuts we use in our process. We do NOT roast our nuts in oil.

After we start with the open flame toasted peanuts, we add one of the healthiest fats on the planet in coconut oil. Let's be real, you eat peanut butter for the healthy fats; we just upped the game by giving you a better version of fats than most nut butters on the planet.

As always with FIt Butters, we use brand name ingredients. We use REAL Snickers in our version of Chocolate Caramel Candy Bar. This gives you a nice chocolate, caramel and nougat flavor. We didn't feel that was enough, so we added in real caramel baking bits to give you that caramel flavor you love.

With all of our amazing nut butters we need to have an amazing protein. We've elected to use NutraOne Protein Creations Chocolate Caramel Peanut Candy Bar whey protein to give you a full amino acid profile and amazing flavor. No, we are not a high protein nut butter, but we are a complete protein nut butter with amazing flavor and textures.


Chocolate Mint Cookies and Cream Cashew Butter is one to drool over. If you're a mint fan, you will NOT want to miss this. What is better than the combination of mint, chocolate and REAL mint Oreos? Not much, that's what. This is a flavor that is so good you can eat it out of the jar by itself, or out it on your rice cakes or toast. Either way, no matter what you choose, you will love this!

Our Chocolate Mint Cookies and Cream is made with high quality Gaspari Nutrition Proven Whey (Hydrolyzed Whey Protein). Hydrolyzed Whey Protein is the highest quality of whey protein you can find on the market. Gaspari Nutrition's Chocolate Ice Cream Proven Whey adds the perfect hint of chocolate along with the creaminess of ice cream to make this a must try.


Our Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup starts with our signature cashew/almond blend to give you that texture and consistency that people are raving about. Then we add in authentic, real Reese's Peanut Butter Cups and Reese's Peanut Butter chips! We don't mess around with the "off brand" stuff. We give you the real deal.

Our Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Cashew Almond Butter is made with high quality Core Nutritionals CORE ISO Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup. Their Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup CORE ISO is one of the top selling flavors from one of the most respectable brands in the sports nutrition industry.


Roasted by the FIt Butter team and blended into a perfect balance of cashews and almonds for a smooth texture from the cashews with some grainy texture from the almonds. This blend is changing the game of nut butters! Cinnamon Sugar Cookie flavor has a great gritty texture resembling the sugar on top of a cookie. A team favorite for texture and taste. The best part is by using a vegan protein, it makes it a 100% vegan protein nut butter.

Our Cinnamon Sugar Cookie Cashew Almond Butter uses high quality plant-based protein from Nutrex Research. We used Nutrex Research Plant-Based Cinnamon Cookies Vegan Protein to ensure that this nut butter is 100% vegan friendly and 110% delicious!


Roasted in the FIt Butter Kitchen, almonds and cashews blend for the perfect smooth and grainy texture. Try this fun new blend of nut butter with a new twist on Dark Dutch Chocolate flavor. For all you amazing chocolate lovers, we had to accommodate and make a rich, Dark Dutch Chocolate flavored nut butter! This rich, creamy, Dutch Dark Chocolate flavor packed with 100% Whey Protein Isolate from NutraBio® for a pure treat! Desert in a FIt Butter, truly. Skip the desert and have a FIt Butter. Life is Butter, FIt.

We pride ourselves on using high quality protein sources in our nut butters. This is why we wanted to work with NutraBio. We use NutraBio 100% Whey Protein Isolate Dutch Chocolate® to capture all of your chocolate lovers heart. Not only is it the highest quality whey protein isolate, it provides a rich chocolate flavor we all can love.


Breakfast to the max! For all you breakfast lovers, here is another amazing blend of Cashew Almond blend from our freshly roasted nuts. Are you catching the trend that we love our blends as the FIt Butter team? Maple brown sugar has a slightly thicker consistency with a great, different maple sweet tone making for a wonderful breakfast all day nut butter! Great on pancakes, waffles and French toast. Time to upgrade your breakfast!

Our Maple Brown Sugar Cashew Almond is made with high quality Primeval Labs ISOLIT Whey Protein Isolate. Their Vanilla Diner flavored whey protein isolate is the perfect compliment to the flavors of maple syrup notes and brown sugar in this cashew almond butter spread.


Remember when your grandma or mom would toss a bunch of delicious ingredients into a bowl, mix them together and make Monster Cookies? Those were the best! We wanted to capture that nostalgia and that deliciousness with our new Monster Cookie Peanut Butter.

The key ingredient in our Monster Cookie Peanut Butter is the use of Purus Labs Keto Feed Oatmeal Cream Pie. The base of a real Monster Cookie is peanut butter and oatmeal, we just captured that with the deliciousness of Oatmeal Cream Pie. This is a whey protein isolate with added MCTs to give you even more healthy fats.


A cashew butter blend for a perfect creamy texture in our Cookies and Cream flavored nut butter. Named after a Ryan’s little girl who loves cookies (and Cookie Monster) and loves this nut butter. Creamy cashew butter flavor with the best crunch of chocolate sandwich cookie bits throughout makes this an experience! Bursting with flavor and creamy delight, try this childhood favorite for a nostalgic flashback to your worry-free childhood with a fun twist of a cashew butter!

We use only the highest quality proteins in our nut butter spreads. This is why we chose to use NutraBio® 100% Whey Protein Isolate Ice Cream Cookie Dream in this amazing creation. Ice Cream Cookie Dream Whey Protein Isolate provides the flavors of a creamy cookies and cream desert that is needed in order for Rory to put her name on this nut butter.


We expect this to be a fan favorite with memories of campfires and family time! Fresh raw Spanish peanuts roasted by the FIt Butters team. A classic treat that everyone wants more of. Add peanut butter to the mix, with real marshmallows, chocolate chips and graham cracker crumbs? And we have a complete win for your taste buds! A classic creamy peanut butter blend for all those lovers of traditional peanut butter.

A perfect S'Mores Peanut Butter needs a perfect S'Mores theme protein powder. We were so excited to be able to use MPA Supps IsoSolve Whey Protein Isolate Graham Cracker Pie Crust in this epic creation. Not only is IsoSolve a high quality protein from MPA Supps, it also adds to the overall experience and flavors that you expect from a S'Mores product.


This is Danielle’s creation due to her love for Salted Caramel! To satisfy that crave for a crunch, we added the pretzels, also adding some extra salt for the Salted Caramel flavor. We roast the Spanish peanuts fresh in the FIt Butters kitchen once again. The popular sweet and salty combination is to die for. The toppings of the sugar-free caramel and crumbles of pretzel makes presentation truly match the amazing taste of this peanut butter blend. Pretty, delicious and nutritious.

Our Butterscotch Toffee Crunch Peanut Butter is made with high quality BEAM Whey Protein Isolate. Their Salted Peanut Butter flavored whey protein isolate is the perfect compliment this this sweet and salty peanut butter.


Raw cashew and almonds freshly roasted in the FIt Butters' kitchen. This nut butter is the original first flavor we attempted to make, and we must say it has held its own as one of the top favorites of the team and our reviewers. The texture is creamy with some grainy texture from the almond and easily spreads as a topping. The blend is delicious and while it has sweet tones as nut butter often do, it’s not overly sweet. Vanilla and coconut, both mildly sweet while complimenting each other in a beautiful balance.

Our Vanilla Coconut Cashew Almond Butter is made with high quality Primeval Labs ISOLIT Whey Protein Isolate. Their Vanilla Diner flavored whey protein isolate is the perfect compliment to the flavors of coconut already used in this nut butter.

Customer Reviews

average rating 4.8 out of 5
Based on 4 reviews
  • 5 Stars
    3 Reviews
  • 4 Stars
    1 Review
  • 3 Stars
    0 Reviews
  • 2 Stars
    0 Reviews
  • 1 Star
    0 Reviews
100% of reviewers would recommend this product to a friend
Review posted
Reviewed by Justin Y.
Verified Buyer
Rated 5 out of 5

5 Stars

Great taste. Helps me with a sweet urge from time to time

I recommend this product
Was this helpful?
Review posted
Reviewed by Ashley
Verified Buyer
Rated 5 out of 5

Dessert in the morning!?

This stuff is amazing! I got monster cookie and the little chunks aren’t just on top like most other brands. This stuff is all the way through. It is delicious! Highly recommend spending the money for this, it is also thinner than most peanut butters so it “feels” like you’re getting more than only 2TB per serving haha :) definitely worth it!

I recommend this product
Was this helpful?
Review posted
Reviewed by Jake
Verified Buyer
Rated 5 out of 5

Love These

Really good product. Easily the best brand ive had.

I recommend this product
Was this helpful?
Review posted
Reviewed by Shawn
Verified Buyer
Rated 4 out of 5

Pricey but great product

A little pricey, but the product is awesome. Great taste

I recommend this product
Was this helpful?